“Consumer fraud”: The new online speech control law?

Originally posted 2008-03-19 13:10:44. Republished by Blog Post Promoter

CONFUSION picense plateGet this:

New Jersey prosecutors have subpoenaed records of JuicyCampus.com, a Web site that publishes anonymous, often malicious gossip about college students.

Language on the site ranges from catty to hateful and offensive. One thread, for example, on the “most overrated Princeton student” quickly dissolves into name-calling, homophobia and anti-Semitism.

JuicyCampus may be violating the state’s Consumer Fraud Act by suggesting that it doesn’t allow offensive material but providing no enforcement of that rule — and no way for users to report or dispute the material, New Jersey Attorney General Anne Milgram said Tuesday.

What a load of baloney! I have litigated the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act frontwards, backwards and sideways, and believe me — this would be an unbelievable stretch. If Milgram’s interpretation were to fly, it would make that statute an omnibus be-a-good-person-online law with essentially no meaningful limitations. Not that I doubt that the Attorney General would love to have such power, but that would certainly be beyond anything contemplated by the New Jersey Legislature when it was passed.

Of course beyond what the Act itself provides, such an application of it would be unconstitutional too.  Unfortunately, neither of those are giant concerns to some judges in the Garden State.

By the way, this is not an endorsement of online defamation, especially when done anonymously. On the contrary. But please, let’s call a fraud a fraud.

UPDATE here from Overlawyered.

email

Tags: , ,

Author:Ron Coleman

I write this blog.

Subscribe

If you don't get enough email (who does?), I can send you LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION® blog posts by email! Free!

2 Responses to ““Consumer fraud”: The new online speech control law?”

  1. December 26, 2008 at 9:04 am #

    who would have standing in such an action?

  2. David Schwartz
    April 7, 2011 at 5:34 am #

    There’s a fast food joint down the road from me that has a sign clearly stating that they permit only one free refill. But they have provided no way for me to complain when people take more than one refill, and even when they see people doing it, they don’t say *anything*! Surely this has to be some kind of consumer fraud.

Leave a Reply