It’s that time of day

Originally posted 2010-11-30 08:00:12. Republished by Blog Post Promoter

Chicago

My kind of town

Even a stopped clock is right twice a day.  Duets Blog reports on an all-too rare occurrence in an item entitled, just a bit too gamely, “Trademark Bullies Beware the Seventh Circuit”::

Actually, not just the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals (governing appeals from the federal district courts in Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin), but the Seventh Circuit is the most recent to reaffirm that our current legal system does, in fact, provide protection against real “trademark bullies” — and more generally — those who abuse the legal process with unfounded Lanham Act claims.

Last week, in Nightingale Home Healthcare Inc. v. Anodyne Therapy LLC, after laying out a complete circuit by circuit analysis of what makes a trademark or false advertising case sufficiently “exceptional” to warrant an award of attorneys fees to the prevailing defendant under the Lanham Act, Judge Posner wrote:

We conclude that a case under the Lanham Act is “exceptional,” in the sense of warranting an award of reasonable attorneys’ fees to the winning party, if the losing party was the plaintiff and was guilty of abuse of process in suing . . . .

Actually, if you’d asked me which would be the Circuit where this would be most likely to take place, I would have answered the Seventh.  But that’s just the old law-and-economics guy in me.

Well, let’s hope it’s catchy.

email

Tags:

Author:Ron Coleman

I write this blog.

Subscribe

There are all kinds of social media formats to subscribe or otherwise follow the adventures of LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION®. Or see the posts-by-email option below.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. ABA-IPL - November 30, 2010

    RT @RonColeman: Comes the Millenium: The Seventh Cir. does right by trademark litigation abuse http://bit.ly/dHSusX | LIKELIHOOD OF CONF …

  2. John Lichtenberger - November 30, 2010

    RT @RonColeman Comes the Millenium: Seventh Cir. does right by trademark litigation abuse http://bit.ly/dHSusX | LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION®

  3. AnnMichelle Hart - November 30, 2010

    RT @AdvertisingLaw: RT @RonColeman Comes the Millenium: Seventh Cir. does right by trademark litigation abuse http://bit.ly/dHSusX | LIK …

  4. DuetsBlog Authors - November 30, 2010

    Thx for the mention, Ron ;) RT @RonColeman Comes the Millenium: Seventh Cir. does right by trademark litigation abuse http://bit.ly/dHSusX

  5. Richard Russeth - November 30, 2010

    RT @RonColeman 7th Cir. does right by TM lit. abuse http://bit.ly/dHSusX | LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION® // #oneforthegoodguys

  6. Walter Olson - December 3, 2010

    Posner on award of fees in trademark suits http://j.mp/fCCsOi [Coleman] http://j.mp/ghSS6R [Kennerly]

Leave a Reply