Register that copyright, and ignore that man behind the screen!

OK, so I’m mixing metaphors on one or more axes at the same time. But this August, 2005 posting from Bill Patry, while not very fresh (though it is to me; I just stumbled on it today), remains very good if — like me — you like to see either naked emperors or phony wizards brought low. The topic is the requirement that copyrights be registered in order for the federal courts to enforce their owners’ rights in them — a pretty straightforward requirement of the Copyright Act and one which some courts nonetheless seem to consider optional. Writes Patry (I have added hyperlinks for better understanding for non-specialists):

The errant courts have all been led astray by Nimmer, for whom, in my opinion, the statute is at best a secondary source to be ignored at will. Nimmer on Copyright reflects an approach of the treatise writer as colossus, striding the legal world and telling courts what the law is regardless of what the law is; a bit like country singer Willie Nelson’s lyrics about being caught in flagrante delicto by a wife and saying to her “Who are you going to believe, your [lyin’] eyes or me”? Judge Tymkovich’s opinion is thorough and methodical in showing why Nimmer is wrong, why the emperor (like Willie Nelson) has no clothes.

I am not, incidentally, advocating for anything involving Willie Nelson and “no clothes.”


Author:Ron Coleman

I write this blog.


  1. LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION » Blog Archive » Sixth Circuit IP - February 25, 2007

    […] Come on, this supposed to be one nation, under McCarthy and Nimmer (and whoever), indivisible!  Please! […]

  2. LIKELIHOOD OF CONFUSION® » Blog Archive » Second Circuit’s “narrowness” embarasses the Great One - July 22, 2007

    […] Michael Atkins reports that the towering colossus of American trademark law, J.T. McCarthy, is embarrassed by the narrow thinking of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals. What did one of the world’s most prestigious appellate courts do to cause such red-facedness in the redoubtable Professor M? […]

  3. turbo texas holdem - July 14, 2008

    turbo texas holdem…

    copyrights drooping combines Triceratops parliamentary …