Walter Olson:
With all his lawyer chums from Milberg-witness days, you’d think Ben Stein could have saved the makers of his creationist movie from stumbling into textbook IP infringements [Myers, again, WSJ law blog].
Ouch. Ben is an odd guy.
UPDATED: But evidently he — or, more likely, his “people” — is not such the slouch in the “fair use” department — WSJ Law Blog snark notwithstanding.
Originally posted 2011-01-10 16:45:18. Republished by Blog Post Promoter
I have seen the movie.. It seems the linked articles were getting their information secondhand.
Imagine was only heard for at most 6 seconds (I didn’t have a stopwatch, but having read this before I saw the movie, I payed attention to that portion) The linked articles say 25 seconds of the song was used. Thats a gross exaggeration.
The context was:
Science guy says something about eradicating religion during an interview. Ben Stein says “Hey didn’t John Lennon say this a few decades ago.” Cut to 6 second clip with the two lines of “Imagine” that speak to ridding the world of religion.
I don’t know that you can call that “textbook IP infringment”.
Wondering what you think about the press release from Expelled:
http://expelledthemovie.com/blog/2008/04/23/executive-producers-of-expelled-no-intelligence-allowed-statement-on-lawsuit-by-yoko-ono/
The comments section for that press release are an absolute train wreck.